Home > Opinion > Is the hostility between India & China a hurdle for India’s UNSC permanent membership?

Is the hostility between India & China a hurdle for India’s UNSC permanent membership?

Author: Tushar Sharma
Last Updated: November 19, 2026 23:37:47 IST

After World War II, as the world searched for peace, institutions were also emerging. When representatives of 50 countries signed the Charter of the United Nations in San Francisco on June 26, 1945, it was recognized that the world was beginning to seek and move towards global peace. After Poland’s subsequent signature, the number of signatories increased to 51, including major powers, as well as representation from various continental powers.

On October 24, 1945, the world was seeking global peace. However, since the formation of the United Nations, many questions have arisen regarding its functioning and institutional structure. Now, 81 years after its formation, it is indeed appropriate to call for reforms. Of particular concern is how to reform the United Nations Security Council, as its permanent membership and veto powers still reflect the power structure that emerged after World War II.

While many countries are emerging in the current global order, this changing power includes powerful countries like India, which actually hold a significant position in today’s geopolitics and international relations. However, India-China relations are proving to be a hurdle in the reforms of the United Nations Security Council.

As per the current structure, the United Nations Security Council currently consists of 15 countries, of which 5 are permanent and the remaining 10 are non-permanent. Countries like the US, Russia, China, Britain, and France are included in the permanent list, while other countries are also mainly raising their voice for permanent membership. A country like India argues that, as a prominent voice in South Asia, it deserves a permanent membership.

However, China’s opposition to this poses a threat to Indian diplomacy. However, China’s role in India’s permanent membership is crucial, as it is the only country in Asia with permanent membership and veto power. Thus, China is not only relevant in the modern era but also represents a key player in any geopolitical challenges that may arise in the future.

To understand India-China rivalry, it’s important to understand that while China advocates for reforms within the UNSC, it doesn’t openly support India’s permanent membership. This silence, in part, betrays its disapproval. The first reason is that China wants to maintain its unique strategic position within Asia and, as Asia’s sole superpower, doesn’t want to see others as equals.

Another reason is that, given the evolving relationship between India and China, China sees itself as a strategic competitor to India. The political competition between the two countries is not limited to the floor of the United Nations but depends on many factors. For example, China wants to maintain its dominance in South Asia in terms of influence and leadership, while this struggle also extends to its strategic presence in the Indian Ocean region.

If India gets permanent membership, it could have the institutional power to influence China’s decisions. The third reason is the India-USA strategic partnership beyond the IndoChina conflict. China’s biggest concern is that if India is given a place in the UNSC as a permanent member, it, along with the US, can have more weight in the decisions of global institutions.

On January 21, 2026, China’s representative, Sun Lei, delivered several remarks on UN Security Council reforms, focusing on the need to promote the participation of developing countries in the Security Council, while African countries should receive special priority.

While it’s clear that China is in favour of reforms, its silence on the subject of India is sometimes overlooked. Thus, the rivalry between India and China is in some way impacting the reforms. India’s desire for permanent membership and China’s opposition to this issue further widen this gap.

For India, achieving permanent membership in the UNSC is not only a matter of global prestige but also an opportunity to voice the interests of developing countries. Therefore, it becomes necessary to understand that the discussion on institutional reforms in the United Nations should not be limited to India’s permanent membership, but a system should be created through which the voice of global power balance and the interests of developing countries can be raised.

However, the key obstacle to reforms is the veto power. The UNSC’s veto system is a crucial analytical issue in India-China relations. Article 27 of the UNSC’s charter mentions the right to vote on any issue, but the disapproval of any single country can prevent that issue from being considered. However, India has been pushing for reforms for a long time. Therefore, India is trying to raise its voice.

While there is competition in India-China relations, there is also a degree of conflict. While both countries are rivals in many respects, both voice the interests of developing nations on the global stage. While India integrates the voices of the Global South with democratic voices in a more inclusive manner, China advocates for the integration of those voices through economic development and multilateral cooperation.

Despite the two countries’ priorities being similar, their lives remain quite distinct. Although relations between India and China initially weakened after incidents like the Galwan Valley, mutual cooperation has since been expected through diplomatic cooperation. One reason for this is that India is one of China’s largest trading partners. China views economic development as a key factor in improving relations with India.

Total trade between India and China for the entire last fiscal year (202526) was $151.10 billion, with China overtaking the US to become India’s No. 1 trading partner. However, India still faces a trade deficit with China. The question here is whether China’s economic strength can also influence India’s engagement with the US.

This can be seen as an indirect factor. Because China’s large economy, its role in global trade, and investments in developing countries are strengthening its international position. So, it will be interesting to see in the coming years in which direction the rivalry between New Delhi and Beijing is taking India’s bid in the UNSC, because while India has bilateral trade relations with China, there is a silent opposition towards India on the international stage.

*Shreyansh Kumar Gupta is a postgraduate student at Department of East Asian Studies, University of Delhi. He completed his undergraduate studies at Banaras Hindu University. Yuvraj Shrivastav is a postgraduate scholar in Political Science at the Centre for Political Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.

Latest News

The Daily Guardian is India’s fastest
growing News channel and enjoy highest
viewership and highest time spent amongst
educated urban Indians.

Follow Us

© Copyright ITV Network Ltd 2025. All right reserved.

The Daily Guardian is India’s fastest growing News channel and enjoy highest viewership and highest time spent amongst educated urban Indians.

© Copyright ITV Network Ltd 2025. All right reserved.