Mumbai man in search of oxygen dies: Who is to be blamed? - The Daily Guardian
Connect with us

News

Mumbai man in search of oxygen dies: Who is to be blamed?

Urvashi Khona

Published

on

Oxygen

I was out on my daily assignment on Sunday, checking the ground reality and bringing the bitter truth about the Covid crisis to the world. While checking on Mumbai hospitals and their plight, I reached Bhabha Hospital in Bandra around 11:30 am. I saw a man in his 50s, suffering from breathlessness, sitting on a wheelchair. He was trying to breathe with a portable oxygen bottle, helped by one of his relatives.

Immediately, I asked video journalist Raju Sharma to capture his plight. It looked like he was not being admitted because oxygen was not available. I tried to speak to the relatives who were continuously on their phones, trying their best to find an oxygen bed in other hospitals. I got to know that the man, Deepak Abhijeet Mhatre, was 57 years old, from Khar Danda, and had been waiting for more than an hour.

He had reported malaria-like symptoms, and his breathlessness had increased that day, after which he had been brought to Bhabha Hospital. His oxygen level was around 45 or 50. The portable oxygen increased it to just 55. But they were being denied admission as oxygen was not available at the hospital. The relatives were trying their luck with the BMC War Room but were not receiving much response. The man, struggling to breathe, looked at me with hopeful eyes, but if only he knew how helpless we are, in this healthcare system that has collapsed and needs some oxygen itself.

I tweeted an SOS alert, seeing how young leaders were taking advantage of social media to reach out to people and help them. Expecting the same, I tweeted about the situation. I did get some calls offering help but then became aware of more hurdles. I was informed how the man had not gotten Covid tests done, which were mandatory. He was in need of oxygen, but as per health protocols, no hospital would admit him without Covid test reports. I wondered how Covid tests had become more important than the basic requirement of oxygen—even for a man struggling to breathe.

By then it was already 1:00 pm. Somehow, I was informed that tests were being done at the Andheri Holy Family Hospital, but one had to reach the testing centre before 2:00 pm. Everyone was worried how a man in such a state could be taken from Bandra to Andheri.

The relatives opted for a basic antigen test from a private lab. The antigen test turned out to be positive and they started looking for a bed or some oxygen. It was sometime between 1:30 and 2:00 pm. Even after following the primary protocols of the system, there was no affirmative response from BMC War Room. “They say they are trying and will inform us as soon as a bed is available,” said Santosh and Shrikant Mhatre, kin of Deepak Mhatre.

In the meantime, Deepak was brought outside the hospital as he had been feeling more suffocated inside. Seeing how we were coordinating and trying our best to make him alright, Deepak seemed to feel sure he would be fine soon, and his oxygen level reached around 60 or 70. This was when I started talking to Deepak and told him not to fear anything and be strong, and reassured him that we were all taking care of things. He smiled at me and simply said, “Yes, I am fine. Just having a bit of difficulty breathing.” In fact, he seemed better than when I had first spotted him.

Around 2:00 pm, I left for another assignment but remained in continuous touch with Deepak’s relatives. Suddenly at 3.00 pm, I got a call from Santosh. He said, “Ma’am, before you left, you spoke to Deepak and he seemed fine, right? His oxygen level was also 80 outside. As soon as he was admitted at Bhabha Hospital, we were called inside. Sometime after he was taken in, we were informed that he’s no more! His oxygen had depleted.”

I had no words. The man was no more. And it all happened within five hours.

It is likely that Deepak had been well—it’s the system that is unwell. Why are there no spaces for suspected patients? Why didn’t the BMC control room give proper guidance? They could have led the patient somewhere with temporary oxygen availability and then shifted him somewhere else. What is happening to people who are not connected to the internet and cannot communicate with others fast?

Only a day before, oxygen shortage had forced the BMC to move 168 Covid-19 patients from six hospitals. One of them had been Bhabha Hospital.

While a war of words goes on between political leaders and parties every day, the lack of oxygen, Remdesivir and tocilizumab has highlighted how we have failed miserably in creating a healthy mechanism. Amid the blame game and mudslinging that politicians are involved in, who’s responsible for the death of 57-year-old Deepak Mhatre? It’s high time now—politics over this deadly virus should stop and politicians should take accountability. Take better action and make the common man believe that humanity still prevails!

The Daily Guardian is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@thedailyguardian) and stay updated with the latest headlines.

For the latest news Download The Daily Guardian App.

News

DELHI HC ASKS ELECTION COMMISSION TO ALLOT COMMON SYMBOL TO AZAD SAMAJ PARTY

Published

on

The Delhi High Court on Wednesday asked the Election Commission of India to allot a common symbol to Azad Samaj Party (Kanshi Ram) for the upcoming assembly elections in five states.

The bench of Justice Prateek Jalan on Wednesday noted the submission of the Election commission and stated that it has no objection to granting a common symbol to the Bhim Army chief Chandershekhar Azad, for his ‘Azad Samaj Party (Kanshi Ram)’ for the upcoming assembly elections in five states. The Election Commission is directed to facilitate this process,” Justice Jalan said. Appearing for Election Commission, Advocate Sidhant Kumar submitted that the petitioner has been allotted a common symbol ‘helicopter’ for three states Goa, Punjab and Manipur while the application for Uttar Pradesh was rejected for being premature, the symbol sought was also not available for Uttarakhand.

Earlier, ECI told the court that it will consider in accordance with the law, Chandrashekhar Azad’s application for allotment of a common symbol for his political party for the upcoming assembly elections in different states.

The petition was moved seeking court direction to grant common symbol for the party to contest assembly election of five states scheduled to be held starting of the next year 2022.

On March 15, 2020, Bhim Army Chief Chandrashekhar Azad had launched his ‘Azad Samaj Party’ on the birth anniversary of Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) founder Kanshi Ram. Chandrashekhar Azad had launched the party in presence of several supporters and workers of the Bhim Army.

Continue Reading

News

SENIOR DRDO SCIENTIST NARAYAN MURTHY GIVEN ADDITIONAL CHARGE OF BRAHMOS AEROSPACE

Published

on

Defence Research and Development Organisation’s Director-General Missiles and Strategic Systems (DGMSS) BHVS Narayan Murthy has been given the additional charge of the BrahMos Aerospace corporation.

“Distinguished scientist Mr Narayan Murthy has been given the interim charge of the BrahMos Aerospace corporation which manufactures the BrahMos supersonic cruise missile for the Indian armed forces,” BrahMos officials told ANI here.

The interim charge was given to him on Tuesday in view of the superannuation of Sudhir Mishra who completed his over the seven-year term in the office on November 30.

Murthy is the Chief Architect of advanced Onboard Computer (OBC) technologies for missile systems and other defence applications. His sustained contributions and technology leadership over the last three decades has been transformative for making India self-reliant in advanced Real-Time Embedded Computers, mission computing systems, and other avionics technologies.

He led the design and development of advanced Avionics for “Mission Shakti,” India’s first Anti-Satellite Missile Test (A-SAT) and Long-Range Missile Agni 5, elevating India into a league of select nations and strengthening indigenous defence capabilities.

Continue Reading

News

CAPTAIN AMARINDER’S BONDING WITH HARYANA CM CONTINUES TO LEAD TO NEW POLITICAL SCENARIO

Published

on

Captain Amarinder Singh, former Chief Minister of Punjab met Manohar Lal, the Chief Minister of Haryana recently leaving everyone with new political speculations. The captain continues to struggle for his political survival after he was removed from the post of Chief Minister of Punjab. Following this, he formed a new party and remained in touch with the BJP.

Even he had a conversation with the Prime Minister Narendra Modi and other BJP stalwarts. In continuation to mentioned above, his meeting with Manohar Lal is being considered another new development. Political experts are of the opinion that Manohar Lal is most likely to help him to get lost political ground in Punjab.

No one can deny that Manohar Lal is in the good books of the PM Modi, Amit Shah, Union Home Minister along with national party president JP Nadda. Thus, it is clearly visible how crucial role he can play for Captain as he is believed to come with an alliance with the BJP ahead of the assembly election in Punjab.

Everyone is familiar with the fact that earlier both Manohar Lal and Singh continued to take on each other pertaining to many issues belonging to both Haryana and Punjab states. Particularly, Sutlej Yamuna Link (SYL), Haryana’s demand of its share in assembly and separate High court emerged as main factors for rift between Manohar Lal and Captain Amrinder, then CM of Punjab.

Singh’s removal from the post of Chief Minister by the Congress party high command led to give birth to new political scenario. It came to know that both stalwarts had long talk over a string of issues, be it personnel or political. Putting aside previous experiences and bitterness, both also involved in discussion about the upcoming assembly elections in Punjab.

Apart from aforesaid, it is worth mentioning that BJP’s bonding with Amarinder Singh is also likely to help the party in Haryana as he owns a well reputation in the state, particularly among farmers. The agrarian community is not in good terms with the BJP-JJP government after the contentious farm laws were introduced by the Union Government.

Continue Reading

News

Ratan Malakar to file nomination as independent candidate

Arup Kali

Published

on

Outgoing co-ordinator Ratan Malakar submitted his nomination as an independent candidate in Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee’s ward after he was denied a ticket. In the list of pre-poll Trinamool candidates announced on Friday, Kajri Bandyopadhyay, wife of CM’s brother Kartik Bandyopadhyay, was made a candidate in the ward of the Chief Minister’s house.

As soon as the name was announced, campaign started and Ratan did not take part in it. On the last day, he submitted his nomination as an independent candidate in ward no. 73. Ratan, who is also the chairman of Boro-9, said: “I have voluntarily become an independent candidate. I don’t want to say anything against anyone.”

In 2000, Ratan stood for the first time as a TMC candidate in Ward No. 71. At the behest of the then Leader of the Opposition Mamata Banerjee, the leaders accepted Ratan as their candidate. He was shifted to ward no. 73 in 2005.

He became a councillor from the ward of the Chief Minister’s house in 2005, 2010 and 2015. But Ratan was not made a candidate this time. Ward 73 is part of the Chief Minister’s Assembly constituency Bhabanipur. On Tuesday, Sachchidananda Bandyopadhyay, former chairman of Kolkata municipality, stood as an independent candidate in ward no 80, after being denied a ticket from ward number 70.

Trinamool is uneasy as there are two independent candidates in the Chief Minister’s constituency. Former Minister Subrata Mukherjee’s sister Tanima Chatterjee has become an independent candidate. Her name was withdrawn after the announcement. December 4 is the last day for withdrawal of nominations.

However, South Kolkata district Trinamool president Debashis Kumar has spoken harshly against Sachchidananda and Ratan. “Many stand as independent candidates for many reasons. Fourth is the last day for withdrawal of nomination. If they withdraw their nomination on that day, then it is all right. But if they do not withdraw their nomination, we will take appropriate action.”

Continue Reading

News

BJP MP ROOPA GANGULY SLAMS BENGAL LEADERSHIP, WALKS OUT OF MEET

Arup Kali

Published

on

Actor-turned-politician Roopa Ganguly raised serious allegations against senior state BJP leadership for being biased while distributing tickets for the Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC) election after she expressed dismay over the selection of candidates for the civic polls during a virtual meeting chaired by West Bengal BJP president Sukanta Majumdar (who was in Delhi), MP Dilip Ghosh and state general secretary (organisation) Amitava Chakraborty.

During a virtual meeting of the BJP on Tuesday, she expressed her anger and stormed out of the room. “Don’t call me to this meeting,” she said. The Bengal BJP will approach the central leadership with her behaviour.

A few days prior to the Kolkata bypolls, the BJP has already announced the list of candidates. After that the political equation within the party is changing. An atmosphere of anger is also being created in some cases. This time, BJP MP Ganguly is against the party.

It is learned that the meeting was held with the pre-vote. Apart from Roopa, the meeting was also attended by BJP state president Sukant Majumder, former state president and party’s all-India vice president Dilip Ghosh. Many more BJP leaders took part in the meeting. During that meeting, she abruptly left it. Sources said the Bengal BJP will inform the central leadership about this.

After that, Ganguly wrote a post on Facebook: “Today my belief got confirmed that Tista death was not a mere accident but a murder. Sorry BJP4Bengal, I am with Gaurab in my little capacity.”

She further wrote, “I understand that the death of Tista is not a mere accident. I will be by Gaurab’s side.” ‘Tista’s husband’s name is Gaurab. According to sources, Roopa is angry that she did not get a ticket in the pre-poll.

After the death of BJP councillor in a road accident, Rahul Sinha stood in front of the body and said there should be an investigation.

A post by Roopa on social media after the recent death of Subrata Mukherjee also made the party uneasy. She wrote, “You have taken Tista, boss. Ma Kali will take something back.” She further claimed that he was supposed to join the BJP before the 2021 elections. But he didn’t like the deal.” She added: “I don’t say all these things. I remain silent. The BJP leadership did not agree with his remarks.”

The BJP was supposed to give tickets to Gaurab, the husband of Tista Biswas. But Biswas’s husband did not get a ticket. So, he will fight from that ward as an independent. Several BJP leaders are also angry over the nomination of candidates. The team has already taken action against a few.

Continue Reading

News

Chautala asks farmers to open borders after farm laws repealed

Published

on

Haryana Deputy Chief Minister Dushyant Chautala on Wednesday said that the farmers protesting on the Delhi borders should return home and open the borders as the Centre has taken back the three farm laws and is ready to talk on the Minimum Support Price (MSP).

Addressing a press conference here, the Deputy CM said, “Now that the Centre has taken back the three farm laws in the Parliament and their MSP demand is ready to be talked about by the Centre, farmers should return and open our borders.” Chautala further announced that the government will withdraw even the “non-lethal” cases against the farmers. “Even the non-lethal cases against farmers will be taken back,” he said.

The Deputy CM appealed to the Centre to replicate the act of the state government of directly transferring the MSP on paddy crops for the last two harvests. “Farmers demanded MSP in Haryana and our govt, in the last 2 harvests, directly transferred Rs 30,000 crores for MSP on paddy crops. I urged the Centre to replicate this all over the nation,” he said.

Earlier this month, Jannayak Janta Party leader Dushyant Chautala welcomed the Centre’s decision to repeal the three contentious farm laws and hoped they would be reintroduced in a better way.

Speaking briefly to reporters in the national capital today, Chautala said, “The Prime Minister has himself said that he could not let the benefits be understood by the farmers. I think now it is high time that we make the farmers understand the benefits and reintroduce the laws in a better way.”

Continue Reading

Trending