Indian YouTuber Ishan Sharma has stirred debate with his criticism of the tipping system in the United States. During his visit to New York City, Sharma encountered an issue at a restaurant where he paid $50 in cash for a $45 meal. The server took the $5 change as a tip, which Sharma was not expecting. In his post on the social media platform X, Sharma described the experience and called tipping in New York a “scam.” He also mentioned that his local friend felt embarrassed and guilty for not paying a higher tip.
Understanding Tipping Practices in the US
To grasp the controversy, it’s essential to understand tipping practices in the US. Tipping is generally expected in American restaurants, with a standard tip being 15-20% of the total bill. This practice is rooted in the fact that many service workers, such as waitstaff and bartenders, earn a significant portion of their income from tips. In the US, the federal minimum wage is $7.25 per hour, but employees in service roles often receive a lower base wage and rely on tips to make up the difference. In contrast, tipping in India is seen as a reward for exceptional service rather than an obligation.
A Divisive Social Media Post
Sharma’s post, which has garnered over 460,000 views on X, has drawn both support and criticism. Many users argue that Sharma should have adhered to local customs, with some suggesting that his refusal to tip was disrespectful. They emphasized the importance of following local norms, with one user writing, “When in Rome, do as Romans do. If you strongly feel that tipping is wrong then don’t order food at a sit-down restaurant.”
Tipping is such a scam in New York!💀
Why do I pay extra just because restaurants pay minimum hourly wages?
Ordered a crepe, club sandwich and Panini for $45(Rs. 3800).
We paid $50 cash and the waiter just took the rest as tip.
I asked for change and she said "you have to pay… pic.twitter.com/9ggEZHIoft
— Ishan Sharma (@Ishansharma7390) August 20, 2024
Critics have also accused Sharma of giving Indians a bad reputation and contributing to negative stereotypes. One user commented, “You are the reason why the globe is becoming racist against Indians. Stop being cheap.”
On the other hand, some users sympathized with Sharma’s perspective, pointing out that tipping customs vary by country. “Tipping is customary in this country. Not tipping is customary in other countries. This isn’t that complicated,” a user noted.
Overall, Sharma’s experience highlights the cultural differences in tipping practices and the complexities of adapting to local norms while traveling.
