It is also known as Lexington Candy Shop, this Upper East Side diner has been revered since its early days for the nostalgic charm of a bygone era and classic Coca-Cola floats served the old-fashioned way.
This diner, established in 1925, recently celebrated its 100th anniversary and continues to attract locals and tourists alike with its vintage menu and timeless atmosphere. The shop represents much more than a dessert destination; it is a living slice of New York City history.
Confusion Over Viral Claims
Recently, there was a social media buzz indicating that Lexington Candy Shop had closed, and its owners were arrested for allegedly laundering over $2.3 million.
Posts indicated that the 97-year-old establishment was suddenly shut down and quickly circulated on most social media platforms like X. The claims immediately picked up steam due to the shop’s iconic status, leading to widespread concern among fans of the diner and foodies across the city.
🚨#BREAKING: A 97 year old NYC diner that still serves their Coke the old fashioned way has been shut down after owners were arrested for allegedly laundering over 2.3 million dollars
— R A W S A L E R T S (@rawsalerts) November 29, 2025
Fact Checking: Separating Rumors from Reality
Closer investigation shows that these reports are completely not true. No news reports from credible news media or official police reports have surfaced of the arrest of owners John Philis or Bob Karcher.
ALSO READ: White House Launches Database Calling Out ‘Biased’ Reporting on Trump
Still operated by third-generation owner Philis and partner Karcher, who has been with the company for almost three decades, the store only closed down temporarily for Thanksgiving Day, following its tradition, and opened promptly afterwards, assuring patrons of the continuity of its operation.
Fact & Fiction Separated
Closer inspection shows these claims are completely untrue. No reports from credible sources of regular media or otherwise have been made of any arrests of owners John Philis or Bob Karcher. The family business, of which Philis is a third-generation owner, with his business partner Karcher having been associated with the company for almost three decades, has undergone no such event.
The store recently closed temporarily, but that was in keeping with its tradition on Thanksgiving Day and immediately reopened afterward, assuring loyal customers that operations continue unabated.
What is the Resilience of a Local Icon
Despite the viral hoax, Lexington Candy Shop has continued to do quite well. The business has taken claims on social media and let people know how much it truly appreciates customers, while promising to keep the century-old tradition alive.
It just points to a lesson-one mustn’t believe everything that’s on the internet, as even historic hotspots can be targets of fabricated speculation.
Disclaimer: This editorial is for informational purposes only and does not imply any legal or investigative claims about the business or its owners.
