THE SAGA OF THEATRISATION - The Daily Guardian
Connect with us

Defence

THE SAGA OF THEATRISATION

It is well-known that while the Army and Navy are fully onboard with the concept of ‘theatrisation’, the IAF still has certain reservations. These reservations were always there and have only resurfaced. The public impression being generated is that there is no solution except ‘shoving it down the throat’ and to implement it by date soon.

LT GEN PR SHANKAR (Retd)

Published

on

A high-level committee of the Vice Chiefs of the three Services, the Chief of Integrated Defence Staff , and representatives of other Ministries are to undertake wider consultations to implement Theatrisation.  It is well known that while the Army and Navy are fully onboard with the concept of Theatrisation, the IAF still has certain reservations. These reservations were always there and have only resurfaced. The public impression being generated  is that there is no solution except ‘shoving it down the throat’ and to implement it by a date in the near future. Such a thought is detrimental to national security and  should not even be contemplated. The need is for an unified warfare strategy, jointness in operations and integration of assets and forces. To achieve that, every component  needs to be on the same page. We should be clear that that the outcomes of Theatrisation must be better than now. Otherwise we will be better off as we are. Hence the nation needs to be cognisant of the concerns of the IAF. There is a need to examine the main concerns of Theatrisation and to address them professionally.

The main concern of the IAF is well intentioned and partly genuine. The basic tenet of air power is to use it in a concentrated manner. It should not be frittered in penny packets. This is especially valid since the IAF is at a depleted strength and force multipliers like AWACs, AEW &C aircraft and flight refuellers need accretions or are due for major refits. It has been suggested that the answer lies in augmenting IAFs strength first. In the interim, the ORBAT needs reorganising  such that the limited force can be brought to bear on targets effectively. Augmenting the IAF strength is a long term issue and Theatrisation cannot wait for that. The answer lies in reorganising the ORBAT and adopting a flexible but joint approach in deployment and  employment of Air Power. As much as the flexibility is required in the IAF, there is a greater flexibility required in the Army. In fact if there are structural flaws  in the Army need correction lest they are carried into a higher system. 

Any long range firepower either based on  direct propulsion (guns, rockets and missiles) or indirect propulsion (aircraft – manned and unmanned) is always at a premium. Also, as the range of action and effect increases the requirement of centralised control also increases. The longer the range , the lesser such assets are available due to sheer limitation of numbers.  High costs and complexity of operations are also contributory factors. Hence they have to be deployed, employed  and controlled centrally (initially at least). Command and control of these assets and task execution can be delegated as the battle unfolds. Firepower must be concentrated at a point in time and space to ensure overwhelming local superiority so that the situation is comprehensively addressed.  Further, air assets which extend reach like refuelers or bestow strategic mobility and capability like heavy lift aircraft or enhance battle field transparency like surveillance , AWACs and AEW aircraft definitely need centralised control. In effect,  certain air assets have to be under central control, no matter the situation. In this entire business of jointness, we must build flexibility. That is what seems to be missing in the entire approach to Theatrisation. I will explain the issue through the way Artillery Divisions are operational in the Army. 

The Artillery Divisions in the Army have two gun brigades and one composite brigade which has long range vectors. Fundamentally the formation is a theatre resource but is placed on the ORBAT of a Strike Corps. However when it comes to application of its firepower, it is the theatre commander who uses it centrally based on his considerations. In the initial stages of the battle, these assets are placed  ‘in location’ to the Pivot Corps. They are also re-deployed and employed for the tasks of the Pivot Corps , on a need basis. While the gun brigades get deployed and can be utilised for Pivot Corps tasks as allocated; invariably, the long range vectors are used for theatre tasks. Interestingly, all theatre level tasks are carried out in conjunction with the IAF based on a joint plan and jointly evolved target folders. Their deployment and employment is totally centralised. As the battle progresses, the Strike Corps swings into action. The gun brigades normally redeploy for the offensive. Even then their employment is controlled at the highest level. The long range vectors could get allotted to the Strike Corps in part, but will always be poised for theatre tasks. The essence of the whole story is flexibility, coordination, and cooperation through concepts like ‘in location’, ‘dispersed deployment’, ‘centralised control’, ‘multiple tasking through multiple assets’ and so on.  The requirement is to develop jointness conceptually. It is not as if the IAF will get frittered away in penny packets if Theatrisation takes place. We need to evolve joint procedures of command and control in a theatre. We need new and forward thinking.

The crux of the problem is more cultural and psychological in nature. Last year, even before the Eastern Ladakh faceoffs started, I had foreseen the issue and outlined it in an article  titled ‘Prickles of Theatrisation of Commands’. We are looking at how to meld two extremes. On one extreme we have an Air Force ‘dashing flyboy’ leadership which rarely identifies with its men. On the other extreme, we have an Infantry predominant ‘boots on the ground’ Army leadership which cannot look beyond its men, its lanyards and deep-rooted regimental affiliations. They have a lot in common. Both have good intentions and have done well for the nation. However, they both feel they are the ‘ONLY’ in their respective systems and the rest are appendages. They have a fixated concept of how war is executed, no matter if it is not relevant to the times. A bit of the lone ranger mentality. They both have exhibited a clannish penchant for cornering goodies of their respective forces at the expense of others. They are extremely good at handling advanced technologies but poor at developing them. They refuse to understand each other. How these two extremities are made to shed their inhibitions and come together on a common platform to work jointly and serve under each other is a great challenge. Both need to be brought to the centre of the road’. The Infantry dominated Army  leadership wants to see the effect of air power in its visual range which is more suited to the close battle. This outlook has been further conditioned by the close encounters during excessive commitment in CI ops. Overall, the Indian Army has veered towards the ‘close battle’ mentality in recent years. The outlook of IAF leadership is unfettered by visual sight and looks deep. It believes in the depth battle. Its main fear is that air power will get divided and committed into penny packets and frittered which will lead to its eventual marginalisation. It could also result in a close battle focus at the expense of the depth battle. Penny packeting might also result in aircraft lying idle when required elsewhere. There is an old maxim – Guns are never left idle. Similarly, in war, a nation cannot let its airpower lie idle. It could be catastrophic. 

The bridge between the two is Artillery which traditionally understands the close battle, has experience in CI ops next only to the Infantry and also thinks deep. With the growth of long range missile and rocket content the Artillery straddles both the spaces. Its traditional role of once merely neutralising the enemy, had morphed to destroying the enemy during Kargil War. It is now transforming to a higher level – deterrence based on extended reach in depth. However the structural problem is that the Artillery has been side-lined systematically in the Army. It  is reduced to a support status with no voice due to many reasons; which are not fully professional. As a result the presence of Artillery in the leadership hierarchy is minimal and marginal. The cannons of India are no more the locks and keys of the nation. In this situation it is for the government to take a review holistically.  It is beyond the actors in this theatre to rectify the situation. They are the problem in the first place. The solution lies in what Winston Churchill said ‘Renown awaits the commander who first restores Artillery to its prime importance on the battlefield’. As much as the Armed Forces need jointness and integration,  the Indian Army leadership needs structural reformation. A re-look at the Infantry oriented ‘General Cadre’, which is now detrimental to the organisation, is warranted. Unless that relook is taken, forcible  Theatristaion will be counterproductive to the nation. The snake will then start to eat its own tail. Indian Army is in a state of leadership and thought imbalance.        

Let me highlight with a personal experience. As a GOC of an Artillery Division, I had occasion to work closely with the IAF. In a major operational exercise based on the deserts, I was once briefing my  COAS, GOC in C, and the Corps Commander. The  AOC in C was also in attendance. I was putting forth a plan which I could sense was not being well received.  At that time it was the AOC in C  who saw merit in my point of view and quizzed me pointedly and repeatedly. He drew out from me to what I was propounding for everyone to see light. Suddenly after a few leading questions a joint understanding and plan emerged to all round satisfaction and benefit. It developed synergy beyond my own belief. The role of the Artillery Division changed from being a mere provider of firepower to one of shaping the battle field and influencing operations along with the IAF. That kind of a thought process has to be instilled if we desire Theatrisation.  IAF cannot be used as traditional Artillery in a support role. Nor can modern Artillery be used in a traditional role. The thinking has to change. In my opinion, the Artillery Division is to mountains what an Armoured Divison is to the plains. It promotes manoeuvre and  reach into the depth.  Along with IAF, it will provide a potent offensive capability in depth. However that realisation has not dawned in the Indian Army for a variety of reasons.

It is also well known that the IAF squadron strength is depleting. While all efforts are being made to make them up, it will not happen in the next decade. We must fight with what we have is the common refrain. However, ‘Airpower’ is not aircraft alone. It includes missiles and rockets also. There is whole new dimension of unmanned airpower opening up. So, look at it comprehensively.  Iran relies on missile based airpower in the absence of a viable air force. Long range precision fires is a priority program of USA. China has deployed long range rockets and missiles in Tibet to offset their lack of airpower in Eastern Ladakh. All these pointers can be ignored at our peril. In the situation we are in, there is a need to increase the inventory of long range missiles held by the Army to bridge the gap due to lack of aircraft. India has the wherewithal, technology and production capacity to do so. It is undoubtedly cost effective. However to make it happen, it needs joint thinking and planning. That is not happening since the Army and IAF are not looking in the same direction. A redressal is needed in this sphere.

One might conclude that I am based and am propagating the case for ‘Artillery’ being a Gunner. However my argument is based on professional reason and facts not filial affiliations. In case we do not have the Artillery bridge in place in the correct slot, we will be destined to fend off the Chinese at short ranges as we have done so now and be ready to redress the situations they create along the LAC and elsewhere in future. The requirement is to keep them at ‘standoff’ through the IAF and Long Range Artillery. If needed we can  fight them at short range with our indomitable Infantry, Armour and tube Artillery. It is not that I love my Infantry or IAF less, it is that I love my nation more and am being upfront. Our Infantry and IAF are great but cannot see eye to eye. Hence I have put across facts as they are. Theatrisation by force or by political edict or by majoritarian outlook will take us back to the philistines.  There are sensible and logical ways forward on Theatrisation so that we can fight as a single entity across the length and depth of the battlefield.  We need to have the mental flexibility and sagacity to do so resolve this core issue of Theatrisation. If we can do that, we are on our way. 

PS :- I have no personal issue with any Infantry or IAF officer. In fact many have been my mentors and are full of wisdom.I respect them.  Many will also ignore me as noise. However unless reason is seen we will face serious consequences.   

Lt Gen P.R. Shankar was India’s DG Artillery. He is highly decorated and qualified with vast operational experience. He contributed significantly to the Modernization and Indigenisation of Artillery. He is now a Professor in the Aerospace Dept of IIT Madras and is involved in applied research for defence technology. His other articles can be read on www.gunnersshot.com

The crux of the problem is more cultural and psychological in nature. Last year, even before the eastern Ladakh face-offs started, I had foreseen the issue and outlined it in an article titled ‘Prickles of Theatrisation of Commands’. We are looking at how to meld two extremes. On one extreme we have an Air Force ‘dashing flyboy’ leadership which rarely identifies with its men. On the other extreme, we have an Infantry predominant ‘boots on the ground’, Army leadership which cannot look beyond its men, its lanyards and deep-rooted regimental affiliations.

The Daily Guardian is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@thedailyguardian) and stay updated with the latest headlines.

For the latest news Download The Daily Guardian App.

Defence

A SALUTE TO THE INDOMITABLE SPIRIT OF KARGIL BRAVEHEARTS

Published

on

o commemorate the 23 years of victory over Pakistan in the Kargil War of 1999, the Indian Army on Monday organised a motorcycle expedition from New Delhi to the Kargil War Memorial at Dras (Ladakh).

The 30-member rally was flagged off by Lt Gen B S Raju, the Vice Chief of Army Staff from the National War Memorial, New Delhi on Monday.

Over the next six days, the team of 30 serving personnel who have embarked on this expedition will endeavour to replicate the indomitable spirit of the Kargil brave-hearts by rekindling the spirit of fortitude, courage and adventure synonymous with the Indian Army, said the Ministry of Defence.

The bike rally would pass through Haryana, Punjab, Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh before culminating the expedition at the Kargil War Memorial, Dras on 26 July 2022.

Continue Reading

Defence

2 ARMY OFFICERS KILLED IN ACCIDENTAL GRENADE BLAST

Published

on

Two Army officers were killed in an accidental grenade blast along the Line of Control in the Mendhar sector of Jammu and Kashmir’s Poonch, the Defence Public Relations Office said on Monday. During the treatment, one army officer and one Junior Commissioned Officer (JCO) succumbed to their injuries.

JCO Sub Bhagwan Singh

Captain Anand

“Last night, an accidental grenade blast occurred in Mendhar Sector, Dist Poonch, when troops were performing their duties along the Line of Control. The blast resulted in injuries to soldiers.

During the treatment, one officer and one JCO succumbed to their injuries, “said PRO Defence Jammu.

According to the Defence PRO, the blast occurred along the Line of Control (LOC) on Sunday night, when the army troops were performing their duties, thus injuring them. All the injured soldiers were immediately evacuated to Udhampur via helicopter.

As per the reports, one officer and one Junior Commissioned Officer (JCO) succumbed to the injuries.

The Indian Army expressed grief over the death of two officers.

The Indian Army tweeted, “General officer commanding (GOC) @Whiteknight_IA and all Ranks salute brave hearts Capt Anand and Nb Sub Bhagwan Singh who made the supreme sacrifice while performing their duties on the LoC in Mendhar Sector. We offer deepest condolences to their family members.”

Continue Reading

Defence

MAKE IN INDIA PUSH: IAF TO INDUCT COMBAT AIRCRAFT

Published

on

Air Chief Marshal VR Chaudhari on Sunday said that the Indian Air Force (IAF) is planning to induct Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA) and Light Combat Aircraft MK-1A and MK-2 along with the 114 multirole fighters. This will be done to bolster India’s combat capabilities through indigenisation under “Make-in-India” in the future.

The IAF chief said that the move will not only “strengthen the Air Force” but also bring a “huge boost” to the Indian aviation industry as part of the Aatmanirbhar Bharat initiative of the Narendra Modi government. “On the aircraft front, we are looking ahead for the AMCA and the LCA MK-1A and also the LCA MK-2 a few years from now. The case for 114 MRFA is also progressing well. With this, it will not only strengthen the Air Force but also bring a huge boost to the Indian aviation industry,” ANI quoted the Air Chief Marshal as saying.

“We have already committed for seven squadrons of AMCA. The numbers for the LCA MK-2, we will take a call as and when the first production model comes out and we start inducting the aircraft into the air force and we can always increase the quantity based on its performance and rate of induction,” he added while speaking about the number of units of the aircraft that the IAF is planning to induct.

When asked about the timeline of the induction of the S-400 air defence system from Russia into the forces, he said that it will be done as per the schedule adding that all deliveries should be completed by the end of next year. “The induction program of S-400 is going as per the schedule. The first firing unit has been inducted and deployed. The second unit is also in the process of getting inducted. Delivery schedules are on time, hopeful that by the end of next year all deliveries will be completed,” Chaudhari said.

“The threat of multiple fronts always exists. The capabilities of the air force in handling two fronts at a time will necessarily have to keep getting bolstered by the induction of various platforms. On the ground, we will need more radars, and additional SAGW systems and all of these are going to come from indigenous sources, for which the action is already at hand,” he added.

The IAF chief further said that the forces are fully in sync with the Centre’s Aatmanirbhar Bharat push which has resulted in the “quick induction” of platforms such as the light-combat helicopter and aircraft and radar systems.

Continue Reading

Defence

SEARCHES FOR SURVIVORS ON, ARMY INDUCTS RADAR

Ajay Jandyal

Published

on

The Indian Army on Sunday inducted radars to trace survivors under the debris which was laid after a cloudburst struck the area near the holy shrine of Amarnath on Friday.“Xaver 4000 radar has been inducted and has been operational at Amarnath since late noon for finding any survivors under the debris,” said Indian Army officials. Earlier, Lieutenant Governor (LG) of Jammu and Kashmir Manoj Sinha on Sunday visited a base camp in Pahalgam and met pilgrims.“The security personnel and administration have carried out an efficient rescue operation. We pay condolences to those who lost their lives. Efforts are underway to resume the Yatra along with repairing the path. Pilgrims should come, we will provide them with all facilities,” Sinha assured.

Rescue operations underway at cloudburst-affected areas of Amarnath, on Sunday. ANI

The Amarnath yatra was temporarily suspended on Friday, till further notice. 

However, the pilgrims have been waiting at the Baltal Base camp for it to recommence.As many as 35 pilgrims were discharged following treatment, Shri Amarnathji Shrine Board (SASB) Officials informed on Saturday.“35 pilgrims have been discharged following treatment. 17 people are getting the treatment and are likely to get discharged tonight. All safe and healthy,” said SASB Officials.The critically injured patients were airlifted to Srinagar.“Critically injured people were airlifted to Srinagar. 2 people who were buried but were alive were rescued. We’re taking all precautionary steps. 41 missing as per Jammu and Kashmir police out of which some were rescued. Yatra may resume within a day or two,” said Kuldiep Singh, DG, CRPF.As per the National Disaster Response Force (NDRF) data on Saturday, at least 16 people have died in the cloud burst incident near the holy shrine of Amarnath.Meanwhile, four Mi-17V5 and four Cheetal helicopters of the Indian Air Force were deployed for rescue and relief efforts at the Amarnath shrine on Saturday.The Cheetal helicopters flew 45 sorties, carrying five NDRF and Army personnel and 3.5 tonnes of relief material while evacuating 45 survivors from the holy cave.Earlier the officials on Saturday informed that the LG chaired a high-level meeting to review the ongoing rescue and relief operations at Amarnath cave.Meanwhile, the Indian Army informed that they have pulled up “critical rescue equipment” to speed up the rescue operations in the affected areas.“Indian Army pulls up critical rescue equipment to speed up the process of rescue operations and route maintenance in view of recent cloudburst of Amarnath in which 16 people lost their lives while several are assumed missing,” said the Indian Army.

Continue Reading

Defence

LET TERRORIST TALIB HUSSAIN NOT A MEMBER OF BJP: J&K BJP CHIEF

Published

on

Jammu and Kashmir BJP chief Ravinder Raina on Monday said the most wanted Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) terrorist Talib Hussain who was apprehended from Reasi district is neither an “active member of the BJP nor a primary member”.

 Speaking to ANI, Raina said, “Hussain is neither an active member of the BJP nor a primary member. There was a letter circular, on the basis of which it is believed that Sheikh Bashir, who is the President of BJP Minority Front of Jammu and Kashmir had appointed Hussain on 9 May.” He termed the reports fake which claimed that one of the two most-wanted LeT terrorists, who were overpowered by locals and handed over to the police, was in charge of the party’s IT cell.

 The BJP leader further said after that Hussain had circulated a letter himself and resigned from the membership of the party on 18 May. “A couple of years ago, Hussain along with with his three colleagues used to come to the BJP office as a media person. He had also interviewed me many times, he used to call himself a reporter for a YouTube channel named ‘New Sehar India’,” Raina said.

 “As a journalist, Hussain clicked photos with us many times in the BJP office. Pakistan terror outfit wanted to target the head office of the BJP of Jammu and Kashmir. It has been done through the targeted medium and carried out such incidents,” he said. “It is too soon to say more on this matter as the investigation is going on. Not only the BJP, but all the offices of other political parties need to be more alert now,” Raina added.

Continue Reading

Defence

INDIAN NAVAL SHIPS SAHYADRI, KADMATT VISIT SINGAPORE

Published

on

Indian Naval Ships Sahyadri and Kadmatt, under the Command of Rear Admiral Sanjay Bhalla, Flag Officer Commanding Eastern Fleet, visited Singapore from 1 to 3 July as part of the deployment to South East Asia. The Republic of Singapore Navy (RSN) and the Indian Navy personnel engaged in social and informal exchanges as part of a cross-visit to improve mutual cooperation. The visit was aimed at consolidating ties and enhancing mutual understanding.The visit of Indian ships helped enhance maritime co-operation and bolster India’s strong bonds of friendship with Singapore that would further contribute towards security and stability in the region. The ships’ visit coincided with Singapore Armed Forces (SAF) Day on 1 July. “Indian Navy’s South East Asia deployment INS Sahyadri and INS Kadmatt under Command of Rear Admiral Sanjay Bhalla, FOCEF in Singapore from 1 to 3 July. Professional and social interactions with Singapore Navy to enhance mutual cooperation and understanding and consolidate interoperability” read a tweet shared by the Indian Navy. It added, “Coinciding with Singapore Armed Forces SAF Day, 01 Jul 22, the ships’ visit strengthens maritime cooperation, bolstering India-Singapore bonds of friendship – contributing towards security and stability in the region.”

INS Sahyadri is an indigenously built multi-role stealth Frigate and INS Kadmatt is an indigenously built Anti-Submarine Warfare (ASW) Corvette. The Indo-Pacific vision of a free, open, inclusive and rules-based region as articulated by Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the Shangri-La Dialogue in Singapore in 2018 is the driving force behind India’s engagement in the region continued to be directed by the Indo-Pacific vision of a free, open, inclusive and rules-based region as articulated by PM Modi at Shangri-La Dialogue in Singapore in 2018.In 2021, Singapore Minister of Defence Ng Eng Hen participated in the inaugural India Ocean Region Defence Ministers’ Conclave (DMC), wherein he conveyed Singapore’s support to India’s leadership to foster a rules-based maritime order in the Indian Ocean region. This was followed by the annual Singapore-India Maritime Bilateral Exercise (SIMBEX), conducted by Singapore Navy and Indian Navy. The exercise involved a virtual planning phase followed by a ‘contactless’ sea phase in the southern reaches of the South China Sea within international waters.During the second wave of the Covid-19 pandemic, Singapore’s position as a logistic hub enabled both the public and private sector to source emergency relief supplies such as oxygen- tanks, cylinders, concentrators, ventilators etc. from Singapore to India.

26 Indian Air Force sorties and four Indian Navy Ships transported substantial quantities of these items from Singapore to India till the end of June 2021.

This was followed by the 5th India-Singapore Defence Minister’s dialogue, which was held via virtual conference on 20 January 2021. Defence Minister Rajnath Singh discussed furthering cooperation and engagement with Singapore’s Defence Minister.

Continue Reading

Trending