Categories: National

One lakh expected, barely 5,000 turn up: Amritpal’s mass appeal under question

Published by
Tushar Sharma

Chandigarh:

The much anticipated return of jailed Khadoor Sahib MP and Khalistani Amritpal Singh to his native village Jallupur Khera on Saturday turned into an interesting political talking point, with the turnout at his grandmother Charan Kaur’s cremation reportedly falling significantly short of the expectations created by his supporters. Despite elaborate arrangements for an estimated one lakh people, barely 5,000 reportedly turned up, raising questions about the actual extent of public support for the controversial MP.

The three hour visit, permitted by a court under police custody, was being closely watched by Punjab’s political establishment. More than three and a half years after his arrest in April 2023, Amritpal’s return was expected to generate considerable public enthusiasm, particularly given the political narrative built around his incarceration and his victory in the 2024 Lok Sabha elections from Khadoor Sahib.

His outfit, Akali Dal Waris Punjab De, had reportedly made extensive arrangements for a massive gathering. Around six to eight acres of land were earmarked for the event, nearly 300 volunteers were deployed, while parking facilities and langar arrangements were made for visitors. The party’s chief spokesperson, Shamsher Singh Padhri, had publicly indicated that nearly one lakh people were expected to attend the cremation.

However, the turnout, estimated at barely 5,000 by political observers, appeared considerably lower than the expectations. The difference between the projected gathering and the reported attendance has become a subject of discussion among political pundits, who were keenly watching the public response to Amritpal’s presence in Punjab.

Political pundits watching public sentiment
The event was not merely a family gathering in political terms. Amritpal’s return offered an opportunity to assess the emotions surrounding him and the extent to which his political positioning continues to find acceptance among people in Punjab.

Political pundits were particularly interested in gauging public sentiment towards Amritpal, whose politics has been associated with Khalistani separatism. His supporters have projected him as a leader commanding considerable public backing, while his critics have questioned the political ideology and separatist narrative associated with him.

The expectation of a gathering of nearly one lakh people had therefore raised the stakes. The reported turnout of around 5,000, if accurate, suggests that the public response may have been considerably below what the organisers anticipated.

There is also a distinction between people gathering to catch a glimpse of a jailed MP returning home after more than three years and those who genuinely support his political ideology. Political observers point out that curiosity, sympathy and political commitment are three different things and should not be confused while assessing a leader’s popularity.

Some analysts also believe that a section of people attending such high profile events could simply be onlookers with free time, rather than committed supporters of the political movement. Consequently, even the presence of a crowd cannot automatically be interpreted as an endorsement of Amritpal’s politics.

Can Khadoor Sahib influence translate into statewide support?
Psephologist PS Bhogal has also cautioned against interpreting the gathering as an indication of electoral support. He observed that disillusioned people were looking for an alternative and some had found one in Amritpal. However, he maintained that Amritpal’s influence remained largely confined to the Khadoor Sahib parliamentary constituency.

This assessment assumes significance as Punjab moves towards the 2027 Assembly elections. Amritpal’s electoral victory in 2024 demonstrated that he could mobilise a section of voters in his constituency despite being lodged in Dibrugarh Central Jail. But whether that support can extend across the state remains an open political question.

His outfit’s organisational strength outside Khadoor Sahib, its ability to mobilise people across different regions and the acceptance of its political agenda among the wider electorate will be important factors in determining its future political relevance.

A watchful SAD and BJP
Amritpal’s return also attracted attention within the traditional Panthic political establishment. Sources indicated that his continued political presence was being closely observed in Shiromani Akali Dal circles, particularly amid discussions about a possible alliance between SAD and the BJP.

For SAD, which has been attempting to rebuild its political base, the emergence of alternative Panthic political voices presents an additional challenge. However, the extent of Amritpal’s influence should not be judged solely by the crowd at one event. His electoral performance, organisational network and ability to retain public support will be equally important.

During his brief appearance, Amritpal, dressed in his usual white kurta, stood near the funeral pyre, placed his grandmother’s photograph in front of him and folded his hands. Supporters showered him with flowers and garlands. Among those present were Akali Dal Waris Punjab De MLA Manpreet Singh Ayali and Mandeep Singh Sidhu, brother of late activist Deep Sidhu. Ayali claimed that Amritpal was being wrongly incarcerated.

Politicians from other parties largely stayed away from the cremation, although the event remained under close political observation.

Tushar Sharma
Published by Taruni Gandhi